Post by pokemoneinstein on Jan 24, 2011 23:24:26 GMT -5
Larx has asked me if I'd like to take over RtC, and I've gladly accepted, so I'll be heading it up from now on! I'm looking forward to it.
So I'll be implementing the "overall suggestions" idea I had in the criteria thread. I may be remembering incorrectly, but I think at least a few others supported the idea. But if, for any reason, anyone is opposed to the suggestions idea, just let me know in a PM and I'll figure something out. This does, however, mean that everybody can rate the users however they want, whether it be percent, points, or any other type of system.
Results: (I'll be converting the x% results into suggestions soon)
Round 1: SuperiorLarxene - 95%
Round 2: lala19357 - 97%
Round 3: LugiaDialga - 93%
Round 4: pokemoneinstein - 83%
Round 5: hnturs12 - 93%
Round 6: Dasgust - 92%
Round 7: tobinus - 93%
Round 8: Pokeneon7 - 85%
Round 9: xxseenyweeny - 90%
Round 10 (1): REGIROCK - Try to make OCs, Try non-techno arrangements
Round 10: (2): SonicWave1000 - Try making more OCs, Try more genres than DnB, Electronica, etc.
Current Nominations:
flameheadshero - 21
xtremethomas - 16
MeanGreenLuigi - 4
AMRTAX - 14
cat333pokemon - 10
AlmightyArceus - 30
pokemonmastertriplex - 9
utuber6061 - 13
wherewolftherewolf - 28
Zach - 23
YannickJason - 10
Lieutinant Potato - 1
Executive Ray - 4
This week on the stands: TheGuitahHeroe
Composition: ?/10
To be honest, I have no idea what to give here. Because I don't play PMD much, I don't know how much you change up the source material your remixes, and because all of the songs of yours I've listened to are from tindeck and I, to be honest, don't pay attention to the names of songs on tindeck like I should, I'm not sure what songs are OCs and what are remixes/arrangements, so this will be blank for now. This is subject to change, but as for now, I'll leave it up to everyone else.
Instrumentation: 7/10
Honestly, the only factor preventing this from being a 10 is that most of your arrangements are techno, or at least most that I've heard. But believe me, every time I listen to a song of yours, I'm blown away by the types of synths and everything you choose, you clearly have a near-mastery of EQ. Keep it up!
Sound Quality: 10/10
Every time I hear one of your remixes or compositions, I am absolutely awestricken. Just every aspect of each your songs is absolutely fantastic! The feeling, the blend of instruments into one whole, everything. Bravo!
Enjoyability: 10/10
Another 10/10, there's not a single one of your songs I don't love. Often they get stuck in my head for days, and they're just captivating! Great work!
Overall: 27/30
Suggestions for Improvement:
The only thing I can really think of is to try more genres. Everything else is pretty constantly great. I'm not familiar with your abilities beyond techno, but I wouldn't be surprised if they're equally as impressing.
So I'll be implementing the "overall suggestions" idea I had in the criteria thread. I may be remembering incorrectly, but I think at least a few others supported the idea. But if, for any reason, anyone is opposed to the suggestions idea, just let me know in a PM and I'll figure something out. This does, however, mean that everybody can rate the users however they want, whether it be percent, points, or any other type of system.
Results: (I'll be converting the x% results into suggestions soon)
Round 1: SuperiorLarxene - 95%
Round 2: lala19357 - 97%
Round 3: LugiaDialga - 93%
Round 4: pokemoneinstein - 83%
Round 5: hnturs12 - 93%
Round 6: Dasgust - 92%
Round 7: tobinus - 93%
Round 8: Pokeneon7 - 85%
Round 9: xxseenyweeny - 90%
Round 10 (1): REGIROCK - Try to make OCs, Try non-techno arrangements
Round 10: (2): SonicWave1000 - Try making more OCs, Try more genres than DnB, Electronica, etc.
Current Nominations:
flameheadshero - 21
xtremethomas - 16
MeanGreenLuigi - 4
AMRTAX - 14
cat333pokemon - 10
AlmightyArceus - 30
pokemonmastertriplex - 9
utuber6061 - 13
wherewolftherewolf - 28
Zach - 23
YannickJason - 10
Lieutinant Potato - 1
Executive Ray - 4
This week on the stands: TheGuitahHeroe
Composition: ?/10
To be honest, I have no idea what to give here. Because I don't play PMD much, I don't know how much you change up the source material your remixes, and because all of the songs of yours I've listened to are from tindeck and I, to be honest, don't pay attention to the names of songs on tindeck like I should, I'm not sure what songs are OCs and what are remixes/arrangements, so this will be blank for now. This is subject to change, but as for now, I'll leave it up to everyone else.
Instrumentation: 7/10
Honestly, the only factor preventing this from being a 10 is that most of your arrangements are techno, or at least most that I've heard. But believe me, every time I listen to a song of yours, I'm blown away by the types of synths and everything you choose, you clearly have a near-mastery of EQ. Keep it up!
Sound Quality: 10/10
Every time I hear one of your remixes or compositions, I am absolutely awestricken. Just every aspect of each your songs is absolutely fantastic! The feeling, the blend of instruments into one whole, everything. Bravo!
Enjoyability: 10/10
Another 10/10, there's not a single one of your songs I don't love. Often they get stuck in my head for days, and they're just captivating! Great work!
Overall: 27/30
Suggestions for Improvement:
The only thing I can really think of is to try more genres. Everything else is pretty constantly great. I'm not familiar with your abilities beyond techno, but I wouldn't be surprised if they're equally as impressing.